Disappearance of Timothy MacColl

Timothy MacColl (born 1984) was a Leading seaman in the Royal Navy who went missing in the early of hours of 27 May 2012 in the Port Rashid area of Dubai.

MacColl's disappearance was investigated by the police in Dubai and by the Royal Navy. In 2014, the Royal Navy issued a death certificate listing death by drowning, despite there being no evidence of this and contrary to his wife's wishes.

Disappearance

MacColl was serving aboard the Royal Navy ship HMS Westminster as part of the ship's seven month security mission in the Middle East.^[1] The ship docked in Port Rashid, Dubai in May 2012, arriving on the 26 and left four days after MacColl's disappearance on the 31.^[2] MacColl spent an earlier part of the day swimming at the Seafarers Mission in Dubai before he and some of his shipmates went out drinking in the town.^[3] The last time that MacColl was accounted for was when they were at the Rock Bottom Café in the Deira area of Bur Dubai. MacColl was put into a taxi to take him back to the ship at 2:00 am local time by some of his ship-mates.^[4] The drive time between the Rock Bottom Café and where HMS Westminster was docked was about 15 minutes.^[5] He never made it on board the ship and there have been possible sightings of MacColl getting into a taxi at 3:00 am local time to head back into Bur Dubai.^[6]

Investigation

The Royal Navy reported him missing later that same day. An investigation was launched by the Emirati police and two Special Branch officers from the United Kingdom were flown out to Dubai to assist in this. Members of HMS Westminster walked the route that the taxi should have taken between the Rock Bottom Café and the location of the ships' berth and also talked to local people in the area.^[5] The port area was searched by divers, dogs and helicopters with heat seeking equipment, but nothing was found.^[3] The police in Dubai interviewed the taxi driver who dropped MacColl off at a tea shack in the port area.^[3]

Checks were made at police stations, hospitals, mortuaries, medical centres and prisons with there being no record of him. His wife Rachael said that the disappearance was completely out of character and that she had arranged to talk to her husband via Skype later on in the same day that he went missing.^[7] Despite not Skypeing with his wife as arranged, Rachael MacColl was not informed of his disappearance for 72 hours, something that she has criticized the Royal Navy for.^[8]

MacColl's family have also been openly critical of the Royal Navy and the Foreign & Commonwealth Office's investigation into his disappearance. They say that they have often been met with a wall of silence, that no information is being passed along and that the Ministry of Defence prevented MacColl's shipmates from wearing yellow ribbons as a tribute to their missing co-worker.^[9] Rachael MacColl and Neil Cunningham (MacColl's uncle, who is a detective constable in Hampshire) flew out to Dubai in January 2013. After the new witnesses came forward, they asked MacColl's former ship mates if they knew anything at all. Cunningham was quoted as saying "197 members of the ship's company in and around Dubai for eight days - I'm sure there's more information that can assist us and encourage the Dubai Police to carry on the investigation."^[10]

Theories

The belief held by the Royal Navy is that MacColl fell into the sea near to where HMS Westminster was berthed, and drowned. This is what they have recorded on his death certificate. However, a new theory came to light when new witnesses recalled seeing another taxi turn up at the ship with MacColl getting in and returning to Dubai.^[11][12]

Subsequent events

When HMS Westminster returned to dock in the United Kingdom at Portsmouth, the crew were instructed to leave a space when they stand on the deck as they were cheered on by family and friends. The lining of the deck, known as Procedure Alpha, is traditional when returning to port for Royal Navy ships.^[13]

In February 2013, Rachael MacColl closed down the Facebook group associated with her husband's disappearance. The group had attracted over 100,000 people and offered up lots of information, but Rachael MacColl said that it just reminded her of what she and her children had lost. By that point, it had been over a year since the family had last seen Timothy MacColl due to him setting sail for the naval mission that HMS Westminster was undertaking. Rachael MacColl described the website as having an adverse effect on all of their lives.^[14]

Two years later, in May 2014, the Royal Navy declared Leading Seaman MacColl dead. His death certificate lists his death as being due to drowning. His wife maintains that MacColl "is disappeared, not missing" and contested the notion that he died by drowning and disagreed with the Navy about declaring death.^[15] The Navy maintain that this was necessary to enable his wife to claim his pension, however, she was also served notice that she must vacate her military Service Family Accommodation (SFA) at Gosport as she no longer had an entitlement to it.^[3]

References